IMO:
172 - cheap, great fun, great for modifying into a car you want.
182 Cup - not cheap, best left as is out of the box save for intake/exhaust (for this noise in particular).
197 - bit of a pig, too sluggish. Owned one briefly, then later had one in my yard for 6 months when a mate went overseas, wasn't too sad to see it go.
200 Cup (Clio 3) - the best of the breed. Nothing will beat a 200 Cup. I can still vividly remember the 15 minutes I drove it up Old Pac 5 years ago. I still want one.